Home       Top Rated       Submit Article     Advanced Search     FAQ       Contact Us       Lawyers in India       Law Forum     RSS Feeds     

Register your Copyright Online

We offer copyright registration right from your desktop click here for details.

Latest Articles | Articles 2014 | Articles 2013 | Articles 2012 | Articles 2011 | Articles 2010 | Articles 2009 | Articles 2008 | Articles 2007 | Articles 2006 | Articles 2000-05

Search On:Laws in IndiaLawyers Search

Mutual Consent Divorce in Delhi
We provide fast, cost effective and Hassle free solution.
Contact us at Ph no: 9650499965 (Divorce Law Firm Delhi)
File Caveat in Supreme Court
Contact Ph no: +9650499965

Main Categories
 Accident Law
 Animal Laws
 Aviation Law
 Bangladesh Law
 Banking and Finance laws
 Case Laws
 Civil Laws
 Company Law
 Constitutional Law
 Consumer laws
 Contracts laws
 Criminal law
 Drug laws
 Dubai laws
 Educational laws
 Employment / Labour laws
 Environmental Law
 family law
 Gay laws and Third Gender
 Human Rights laws
 Immigration laws
 Insurance / Accident Claim
 Intellectual Property
 International Law
 Juvenile Laws
 Law - lawyers & legal Profession
 Legal Aid and Lok Adalat
 Legal outsourcing
 Media laws
 Medico legal
 Pakistan laws
 Real estate laws
 Right To Information
 Tax Laws
 Torts Law
 Woman Issues
 Workplace Equality & Non-Discrimination
 Yet Another Category

More Options
 Most read articles
 Most rated articles

Subscribe now and receive free articles and updates instantly.


Published : March 13, 2011 | Author : sugyatachoudhary
Category : Educational laws | Total Views : 16461 | Rating :

My name is Sugyata Prakash Choudhary. I am a student of law presently studying in the second year of the five year course from The Government Law College, Mumbai. I am a resident of Mumbai since birth.

A Critique on the Right to Education Act.

What happens when a country of the size of India has over 3 million children living on the streets? Or has over 150 million children working as bonded labourers? Or one out of every six girl child does not live to see her 15th birthday? What happens when despite having a national policy for compulsory primary education, only 50% of children have access to education?

The statement "Children are the future of the nation" stops making sense, then! In fact, it sounds like an ominous prophecy. For how can we explain that even after 63 years of independence, half of India's children are illiterate? Despite identifying primary education as a key thrust area and possessing one of the largest networks of schools in the world?

It is a popular saying that “Education is both the means as well as the end to a better life”. means, because it empowers an individual to earn his/her livelihood and the end because it increases one's awareness on a range of issues. But unfortunately in today’s modern day scenario the subject of Education is actually used by our political leaders and legislators as the “means” for achieving the “end” common to them all. Political power. After all it makes an integral part of their Election manifesto.

The Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009, popularly known as the Right to Education (RTE) Act, came into being in India from April 1, 2010. The Act is a remarkable step forward in the field of education in India. However, some of the provisions of the Act, although included with noble intentions, will have unintended consequences that might counter some of the advantages of the new system itself as well has have ill effects on the very subjects of the Act, the children , most of whom are even unaware of the polity behind the legislation ruling them.

The Act suffers from some serious flaws, many of which have been objected upon by the state governments and the professionals related to the field of education, from teachers to parents to our very own students.

Section 16 of the Act, provides that No child admitted in a school shall be held back in any class or expelled from school till the completion of elementary education. While it is true that failing a child may well cause the child to intensely doubt his or her abilities, the Government fails to appreciate that failing a child also serves as a protective mechanism. The term “fail” has always worked as a deterrent for a child to study seriously and perform well. Failing, actually serves as a blessing in disguise for the students. Also, detaining the child in the same class ensures that the child learns the particular set of skills required for his/her development and hence is a more scientific approach. Promoting the child to the next class regardless of his performance in the previous class would also, in a way, be treating the less meritorious students at par with the ones who have worked hard and meritoriously achieved a place in the next level which is unfair to the good students.

The system then provides for special attention (through Section 4 of the Act) for such a child in the higher class to make up the deficiency in skills and ability. The critical question is – can a child who is unable to bear the workload of a junior class now deal with the workload of a senior class in addition to taking special classes? The embarrassment of failing, which under a system of failing a weak student is corrected at the first stage of inadequacy, now carries over into senior classes.

Failing also provides a feedback to the teachers as well as students. Both the skills of the student and the teaching skill of a teacher are put to test. However, the present legislation dismisses this advantage. A child who does not learn the value of accountability, performance, and hard work in the initial stages of its schooling will be ill-equipped to meet these constants of life in later stages. Failure makes the students accustomed to handling pressure and dealing with stress. The present system simply makes the child ignorant to the realities of life.

Schools which do not have a certificate of recognition from the local authority or government shall no longer be allowed to function, under Section 18 of the Right to Education Act. If such a school is already functioning, the Act prescribes that it be shut down within 3 years if it fails to meet norms. If a new school is set up, it must conform to the norms for a school as laid out in the Schedule of the Act, or be shut down within three years. This brings before us two important facts. It is erroneous to conclude that private, unrecognized schools offer a quality of education that is less than that offered by recognized schools, and banning private unrecognized schools further aggravates the problem of scarcity of formal education institutions.

Section 17(1) of the Act prohibits physical punishment or mental harassment of students. While a ban on physical punishment is laudable, the one on mental harassment is incompletely defined. What, after all, is ‘mental harassment’? It could be anything from a light admonition for not completing homework to vile abuses meant to strip the student of all self-respect. The Act sheds no further light.

Section 28 of the RTE Act mandates that no teacher should engage himself or herself in private tuition activity. The primary reason why teachers under perform in the classroom and then require their students to attend private tuitions is the want of additional income, unfettered by a loose monitoring and punitive system. Banning teachers from taking private tuitions does not do away with the cause of the problem. Even if private tuitions by teachers are successfully done away with, it still does not address the prevalence of teacher underperformance and absenteeism. Section 24 of the Act prescribes punitive measures to be undertaken in case absenteeism and non-performance of duties is observed. While it prescribes the minimum duties to be undertaken by each teacher, no specification is made of what constitutes high performance.

While the intention of the Government (through the RTE Act) in providing free education to children till the age of 14 years is laudable, there is also a need for measures to ensure that children (especially poor children) do not drop out of school once they lose the benefit of free education.

The implementation of the provisions of the RTE Act will be no simple matter either. The other shortfalls aside, the availability of funds and teachers remain significant roadblocks in the implementation of the Act. The Act, which has made education a fundamental right of ever child, will require an investment of Rs 1.71 lakh crore for the next five years for implementation. Recently, Delhi Government violated The RTE Act, 2009 by subjecting children to screening procedure for admission to Class VI in Rajkiya Pratibha Vikas Vidyalayas in the academic year 2010-2011.On the other hand The State Governments demand for cent percent finance from the central government. In reply to them the Centre regards Education as an essential State subject and hence puts the onus of 35 percent of the finance on the state. The war of words still continues. The sad reality is that the future and education of 3 million poor children is juggling between the central government and the state governenment and their political motives. The Act has also been criticized for its hasty drafting. The Question still remains. Should the future of Indian children be dependant on the faulty drafting of laws in a country which is the largest democracy in the world? Can a country, who is a signatory to many international conventions, who is one of the fastest growing economy in the world, not provide adequate , good quality education for her children?

Clearly, we have a lot to answer for. And as concerned citizens do something about it; something meaningful, something concrete, something urgently. No more do we have the luxury of blaming the system or postponing our actions. The time to take collective as well as individual responsibility to remedy the present situation is here. Right now! And also we need many more Smiles to cater to the vast number of children in our country's population.

Authors contact info - articles The  author can be reached at: sugyatachoudhary@legalserviceindia.com

1 2 3 4 5
Rate this article!     Poor

Most viewed articles in Educational laws category
• A critique on the Right to Education Act.
• Legal education system in India
• Right to Education
• Problems and Challenges before Law Teachers in India
• Educational scenario of India
• Reservation Policy in India – A Serious Threat To The Nation
• Legal Education-A Need of Reform
• Change in Reservation Policy
• The Great Indian Reservation System
• What OCI Holders Should Remember before Appearing in NEET?
• Reservation Policy in India - A Serious Threat To Nation
• The Reservation policy of India: needs to be amended
• Infructuous Reservation
Most recent articles in Educational laws category
• The Reservation policy of India: needs to be amended
• What OCI Holders Should Remember before Appearing in NEET?
• The Great Indian Reservation System
• Reservation Policy in India - A Serious Threat To Nation
• Change in Reservation Policy
• Infructuous Reservation
• Reservation Policy in India – A Serious Threat To The Nation
• Legal Education-A Need of Reform
• Legal education system in India
• Right to Education
• Educational scenario of India
• Problems and Challenges before Law Teachers in India
• A critique on the Right to Education Act.

Article Comments

Posted by ankan on May 28, 2015
Fab ..article. .... thing is government school know tat making policy is one thing , ensuring they get implemented is another.... ...five year done the line.. We still remain one of the least educated developing countries in world.....

Post Your Comments


Your comments

Note : Your email address is only visible to admin, other members / users cannot see it.

You can use following FXCodes

BOLD : [b]
Italic : [i]

[b] Legal Services India [/b] is a [i]nice website[/i].
[url= http://www.legalservicesindia.com/article/ ]click here to visit.[/url]

Legal Services India is a nice website.
Click here to visit


Note : Currently, user comments are moderated and will be posted only after approval.

Please login or register a new free account.

Random Pick
Law is a noble profession. Lawyers and Courts have always been the last refuse for the helpless and the harassed litigants. But for late there is erosion of people’s, trust and faith in the Indian judicial system...

» Total Articles
» Total Authors
» Total Views
» Total categories

Law Forum

Legal Articles

Lawyers in India- Click on a link below for legal Services

lawyers in Chennai
lawyers in Bangalore
lawyers in Hyderabad
lawyers in Cochin
lawyers in Pondicherry
lawyers in Guwahati
lawyers in Nashik

lawyers in Jaipur
lawyers in New Delhi
lawyers in Dimapur
lawyers in Agra
Noida lawyers
lawyers in Siliguri

For Mutual consent Divorce in Delhi

Ph no: 9650499965
For online Copyright Registration

Ph no: 9891244487
Law Articles

lawyers in Delhi
lawyers in Chandigarh
lawyers in Allahabad
lawyers in Lucknow
lawyers in Jodhpur
Faridabad lawyers

lawyers in Mumbai
lawyers in Pune
lawyers in Nagpur
lawyers in Ahmedabad
lawyers in Surat
Ghaziabad lawyers

lawyers in Kolkata
lawyers in Janjgir
lawyers in Rajkot
lawyers in Indore
lawyers in Ludhiana
Gurgaon lawyers


India's Most Trusted Online law library
Legal Services India is Copyrighted under the Registrar of Copyright Act ( Govt of India) © 2000-2017
 ISBN No: 978-81-928510-1-3